Time to Repeal the Ethanol Mandate
Heritage Foundation
by Ben Lieberman and Nick Loris
May 15, 2008

Though intended to help consumers and reduce greenhouse gas emissions, the ethanol mandate has done just the opposite, contributing to high food and gas prices with little environmental benefit. Representative Jeff Flake (R–AZ) has introduced H.R. 5911, the Remove Incentives for Producing Ethanol Act of 2008, which would eliminate the mandate and other benefits for ethanol, and other measures may soon be introduced.

A return to a free market for ethanol would be a welcome step. Congress should eliminate the ethanol mandate, ethanol-related tax breaks, and protectionist tariffs that keep out potentially cheaper foreign supplies.

A Growing Mandate

Renewable fuels, and particularly corn-ethanol, have long enjoyed preferential treatment from the federal government. This includes a tax credit worth $0.51 per gallon. In addition, tariffs discourage imports of ethanol, including potentially cheaper sugar cane–based ethanol from Brazil.

Yet the ethanol industry still wanted more, and Congress, concerned about high gas prices, global warming, and domestic energy production, enacted a mandate. The 2005 energy bill contained the first-ever requirement that renewable fuels be mixed into the gasoline supply. The 2007 energy bill increased the mandate substantially. The U.S is now committed to using 9 billion gallons in 2008, rising to 36 billion by 2022.

Ethanol and Fuel Costs

With pump prices rising to record levels, consumers are not seeing the promised benefits from ethanol use. Proponents of the mandate insist that without ethanol, prices would be even higher, but this is not likely.

The logistical and regulatory costs of mixing ethanol into the fuel supply raise the cost of driving beyond the level imposed by plain gasoline usage. Unlike gasoline, ethanol cannot be shipped via pipelines and must be transported via rail, barge, or truck. Ethanol use also complicates compliance with some Environmental Protection Agency regulations for gasoline, especially those designed to fight summer smog. Most significantly, as the American Automobile Association and others have pointed out, ethanol use lowers fuel economy.[1]

Ethanol and Food Costs


Diverting corn from food to fuel use has raised food prices. At a little over $2 per bushel when the 2005 energy law was signed, the price of corn has surged above $5 per bushel, primarily because a quarter of the crop is now used to produce energy. A host of corn-related foods, such as corn-fed meat and dairy, have seen sharp price increases. Farmers, realizing the benefits to be derived from producing corn, are switching from soybeans and wheat, reducing the supply and contributing to the price rise.

For corn farmers, the mandate has exceeded their wildest dreams, but for consumers, it has been an expensive hit—higher costs to drive to the supermarket and higher prices once you're there. A recent study from Purdue University puts the added food cost from the renewable mandate at $15 billion in 2007—about $130 per household.[2] The impact thus far in 2008 is even higher.

The effects of America's ethanol policy, as well as similar food-for-fuel policies in Europe, are felt globally. Several United Nations and anti-hunger organizations have weighed in heavily against current policies. World Bank President Robert Zoellick has acknowledged that "biofuels is no doubt a significant contributor" to high food costs, adding that "it is clearly the case that programs in Europe and the United States that have increased biofuel production have contributed to the added demand for food."[3] There has been food-related rioting in several developing nations.[4] Although a number of factors have led to this, biofuels mandates are undeniably a contributor and exacerbate any other pressures on food prices.

Repealing the ethanol mandate would have an immediate effect on food prices. A study conducted by the International Food Policy Research Institute found that placing a moratorium on biofuels in 2008 would decrease corn prices by 20 percent and wheat prices 10 percent by 2009–2010.[5] The faster Congress acts, the quicker consumers will see a drop in food prices.  [Read More]

Books

Energy Keepers Energy Killers by Roy Innis

This powerful book documents the destruction planned in every community in the United States by the assault of the Energy Killers invading the world.

Al Gore Wants This Book Banned!

Fox News' Sean Hannity says if you read it and act on its message, "You will change the world."
Change the world - Buy this Book




Latest

Ads combat Senate climate bill

A conservative, free-market advocacy group, The Club for Growth, is airing radio and television ads to counter a Senate bill on climate change.  The purpose of the ads is to explain to the public the extent to which the legislation could damage the economy, should it pass. "The number of jobs that will be lost, the rise in price in gasoline and electricity, the loss in GDP -- it's all astronomical.  And we think it's important for people to know what's going on ..."  The legislation is a "massive redistribution of wealth," and the organization is asking concerned citizens to call their senators and urge them to oppose the measure.

 

Press


SMARTGREENUSA  LAUNCHES GLOBAL WARMING ATTACK
EXPOSING ECO-HYSTERIA AND STOPPING GREEN GENOCIDE

WASHINGtTON, DC
- SmartGreenUSA is exposing ‘Eco Hysteria;’ the Eco Hysteria ignited by climatologists, politicians and government commissions that ignore good science and create laws that kill people and the economy.






Search for gas prices by US Zip Code


Al Gore Wants This Book Banned!

Energy Keepers, Energy Killers
By - Roy Innis

This powerful book documents
the destruction planned in every
community in the United States
by the assault of the Energy Killers
invading the world.

Fox News' Sean Hannity says if you
read it and act on its message,
"You will change the world."

Change the world - Buy this Book


Price of Addiction
###
to Foreign Oil

gas tax


SmartGreenUSA
is committed to continuing environmental progress and Smart-Green initiatives. We are dedicated to pursuing the best science available, to evaluate the costs and economic impact associated with the ideas, products and policies proposed as “green” and to be your voice to remind the government that they are elected to serve the people, not to rule over us.  We fought a battle to ensure the right to be governed over 200 year ago.  With your help we will continue to fight for your rights.

DONATE
to
SmartGreenUSA

Thank you for your generous support to help SmartGreenUSA protect America.



"A nation of well informed men who have been taught to know and prize the rights which God has given them cannot be enslaved. It is in the region of ignorance that tyranny begins." 
Benjamin Franklin


"The liberties of our country, the freedom of our civil Constitution, are worth defending at all hazards; and it is our duty to defend them against all attacks. We have received them as a fair inheritance from our worthy ancestors: they purchased them for us with toil and danger and expense of treasure and blood, and transmitted them to us with care and diligence. It will bring an everlasting mark of infamy on the present generation, enlightened as it is, if we should suffer them to be wrested from us by violence without a struggle, or to be cheated out of them by the artifices of false and designing men."
Samuel Adams

Exposing the truth  - Making a difference in this world while I am here.
~ Patrick Hughes ~
SmartGreenUSA